14 Jan, 2010

A Sad Day for The Internet in Jordan: a gag order

Posted by: BamBam In: a post by BamBam| jordan

I've been tagged!
Image by zawtowers via Flickr

A Jordanian court has ruled that Internet sites should adhere to the print & publications(Media) laws that governs the work of print media. As a consequence all the penalties that are extended by this law will be applicable to anyone that is posting anything on the internet.

The reasoning for this stems from the argument that the wording of the print & publications law defines print as ” any publication that is used to document meanings, words or ideas in any method

The case that opened this topic is of one Ahmad Salameh, former chief of Al-Hilal newspaper and journalist

who claimed that he had been slandered by Ammon and Rum news sites. I didn’t read of any proof provided of what harm was caused to Mr.Salameh other than the words that where used by the sites.

Now I’m sure that those words really hurt his feelings. I feel for him, I really do…

Either way the consequence of this ruling is the following, ready boys and girls of the blogging and internet age?

First of all the list of No’s. If you do any of those you’ll subject to a fine that’s between JOD 15,000 – 25,000:

Anything that goes again national responsibility

Anything that goes against Human rights

Anything the goes against islamic and arabic sensibilities

Anything that would harm the King and the royal Family

Anything concerning the Jordanian armed forces or security apparatus unless otherwise authorized

Anything ridiculing any of the religions or sects recognize by the constitution

Anything that harms the national unity and incites on committing crimes

Anything that ridicules, disses or slanders heads of Arabic, Islamic, or friendly states, or disturbs Jordanian relationships with other countries

Anything that promoted deviancy and corrupts morals

Any False information or gossips that harm public interest, Government institutions or those who work in it.

Any information related to the secret session of the national council

Any non-disclosed government documents

Anything that would shake the confidence people have in the national currency

Second: the head of a publication (i.e. everyone on Web 2.0 is a publisher FYI) is the owner of everything published in their publication. That means that internet sites take responsibility for those damn trolls and it’s really easy to frame someone by just trolling their site.

Third: Anonymous publications are banned, every publication should include the REAL name of it’s author and his address. Avatars, anonymous blogging, guest commentators and anyone else who does not include their address is not allowed. Now think with me how smart it will be to post your home address when commenting on the internet ?

The upside to all of this that the law stipulates that the only thing that Jordan can do to foreign publications that break this law is bar their import to Jordan. so the worst, logically, thing that could happen is that they block your site…Way to go if you want to improve Jordanian IT industry. Practically you might have just maimed a whole sector of IT because everyone will be scared to host their websites locally ! Never Mind about any of the social networking sites like watwet who are now being held responsible for everything any of their users say on their service.

Imagine if Yahoo or Google was held responsible for anything their users will say on their networks, how crippling will that be to innovation?

So thank you so much Mr. Ahmad Salameh for bringing this on us.

The really funny part of this is that today there was another news item about media freedoms which talked about how unfair they were and how they didn’t reflect the reality in the kingdom … OOPS

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

33 Responses to "A Sad Day for The Internet in Jordan: a gag order"

1 | mab3oos

January 14th, 2010 at 1:24 pm

Avatar

Here, this comment is going to cost you 15k-25k.

But, here is my address (may be they’ll give you a discount!):

mab3oos el Garfan
15 Yemen Rd, Yemen

2 | Rana

January 14th, 2010 at 1:48 pm

Avatar

Khalas. Let’s all move to Saudi or Yemen. at least they don’t pretend to be “liberal” and modernized.

3 | uberVU - social comments

January 14th, 2010 at 1:49 pm

Avatar

Social comments and analytics for this post…

This post was mentioned on Twitter by bambambi: New Post http://bit.ly/4oRFLp...

4 | Amer

January 14th, 2010 at 1:58 pm

Avatar

They’re becoming like Saudi!!!!
what’s next blocked website for adult content!!
or the might as well just block Tinyurl like Saudi right now!!

5 | Happy for one thing

January 14th, 2010 at 3:29 pm

Avatar

Although I do not like the decision but it is good for Amoon and Rum in specific, because they are not jounalism and harm what is called jounalism. They only look scandels without even checking if it is correct or wrong.

My recommendation will be shut these off and any other similar sites and keep the freedom of journalism.

6 | BamBam

January 14th, 2010 at 3:44 pm

Avatar

@Mab3oos Grr thats not just a fine but a wire tap as well …
@Rana you are right, they don’t pretend to be liberal at all

@amer lol i think that would reduce the bandwidth usage on jordanian ISP’s if they block adult content

7 | kinzi

January 14th, 2010 at 3:46 pm

Avatar

NO BLEEPING WAY!!! Serious???

8 | BamBam

January 14th, 2010 at 3:49 pm

Avatar

@Happy for one thing
I know a person that has a flu if i was a doctor and work on your suggestion i’ll have to amputate his head !
There is nothing good about the decision, if Amon and Rum are so corrupt and spew a lot of lies then people will loose confidence in them and they wither and die without having the rest us killed in the process.
Actually their presence is a testimony to freedom of press since they encourage honest journalism and fact checking, hence increasing the entire level of publication in journalism.
I don’t like them either but they sure as hell serve a pretty damn good purpose. What’s even sadder is that there are a lot of people in support of this decision and they are just being short sighted

9 | BamBam

January 14th, 2010 at 3:54 pm

Avatar

@kinzi yes bleeping way, the good thing is that so far their is no mechanism for enforcing it and the law would probably need to be amended to fit with internet usage.
So lets hope things remain that way, although this case sets the precedence for the future unless they reverse it somehow.

10 | Mohanned

January 14th, 2010 at 4:17 pm

Avatar

هاد كلو بفضل جلالة سيدنا الله يطول عمرو و يحفظو النا..يعني أكيد همه عندهم اسبابهم إلي احنا ما بنعرفها، و أي واحد بحكي غير هاد الحكي بكون بعمل لمصالح اجندات خارجيه هدفها زعزعة أمن البلد وحل القضيه الفلسطينيه على حساب الأردن..يعني اذا سمير ما طلع ذي زيد مين بدو يطلع يعني؟ ماشالله عليه خيار موفق من جلالة سيدنا الله يطول عمرو..ولسة الخير بالجايات..مصلحة الوطن تقتضي إنو كلنا نطوبز…قصدي نتنازل شوي..

Nabil El sharif ain’t got nothing on me..

11 | BamBam

January 14th, 2010 at 4:20 pm

Avatar

i’m up to 50k with that one mohanned, though i got to say that reached the level of “The flipper” more so than the “The honrable” one…oops
75k

12 | Mohanned

January 14th, 2010 at 4:25 pm

Avatar

:P
Turkey removed six zeros from their currency, soon maybe we will be adding those same six zeros..so I wouldn’t be that worried about the 75k ;)

13 | Mohanned

January 14th, 2010 at 4:50 pm

Avatar

on a more serious note..The move is smart, and the wroding is even smarter..They are the masters of ambiguity and uncertainty, the best “soft” detterence tools..

14 | BamBam

January 14th, 2010 at 4:54 pm

Avatar

Whats interesting is that a few days ago i was wondering what effect would the fact that Balawi was a blogger and a fora admin have on the internet in jordan… i got my answer today. this is gives a mechanism for not only monitoring but enforcing rules on internet speak.

15 | Mohanned

January 14th, 2010 at 5:08 pm

Avatar

I thought the emergency laws passed after the hotel bombings gave enough tools to go after online jihad-knowing that the security apparatus in jordan don’t need to abide by laws..But anyway, weren’t they the ones that enabled him and others like him?

Here is what I think..They won’t use the law, but they will keep it in their arsenal,just in case..

16 | kinzi

January 14th, 2010 at 6:49 pm

Avatar

So I guess Jordan deserves that Freedom House ranking after all.

So…do we keep blogging as usual? What say you?

17 | The Jordanian Government

January 14th, 2010 at 7:04 pm

Avatar

What you need to understand is that we (and I speak for the entire government here) are infallible. If you remember the following two rules, you’ll do just fine:

1) The government is always right.

2) In the case where the government looks like it might be wrong, see rule #1.

P.S. We’ve logged all of your IP addresses, you usurpers of government authority.

19 | 7aki Fadi

January 15th, 2010 at 5:41 am

Avatar

As Mohanned said, the rules are so ambigsiuos that it could be anything from using the F word, swearing at a ” head of state” or simply not beliving in God.

They will not monitor any blogs, they just have the rules so they can shut down people who have half a brain.

You know what, Eff this sh*t . take that no. 17 . LOL

20 | Mayel

January 15th, 2010 at 10:26 am

Avatar

so this how they will do it …first they will catch 10-20 people and put them in jail or force fine out of them, this will scare alot of people ,then they will try to calm it abet.
so what are you going to do about it …
always the answer is clear go west …it’s a great song

21 | BamBam

January 15th, 2010 at 1:29 pm

Avatar

@kinzi Hell ya !

@the gov’t …err Dave … hmm do i see a moooole

@7akifadi … its not really the prospect of blogs or other platforms related to the journalism in any way. they are like The whole internet is MINE ! Thats the scary part … like leaving a comment that would incriminate you on your FB is within this laws reach… maybe

@mayel but whats the point of doing that? we already knew that this could happen at any point. the timing and the way they did it was too sly

22 | Tala

January 15th, 2010 at 7:01 pm

Avatar

hmmm I didnt understand, is it the job of the juridical authorities to decide so in the first place? isn’t there a ministry of information and communications for that purpose?

how did they conclude that there are 100 sites that should adhere to the law? this is stupid because its impossible, unless they want to administrate every website and service !

23 | Looks Like It’s Back to Cookie Blogging « my treasure

January 15th, 2010 at 9:54 pm

Avatar

[...] the Jordan Times (thx for reminding me, Momma Bean, I read about it at Bam’s and went straight into denial) “The court’s decision, issued last week but published only [...]

24 | BamBam

January 16th, 2010 at 12:38 pm

Avatar

@tala nope … the ministry of information would theoretically regulate the service and the infrastructure and wouldn’t be interested in micro managing the internet

25 | Global Voices Online » Jordan: Bloggers Take On Controversial Court Rule

January 17th, 2010 at 9:13 am

Avatar

[...] to these efforts, BamBam goes over the list of things that may no longer be discussed in the Jordanian web: Anything that [...]

26 | Ebtihal Mahadeen

January 17th, 2010 at 1:37 pm

Avatar

Hello,

Your post was included in GV’s roundup of the current discussion in the Jordanian blogosphere. However, Eyas Sharaiha has left a comment indicating that your post may contain inaccurate reading of the current Press and Publication Law. This is an invite for you to address his comment on GV: http://globalvoicesonline.org/2010/01/17/jordan-bloggers-take-on-controversial-court-rule/

27 | Jordan: Tightening the Noose on Freedom of Speech | And Far Away

January 20th, 2010 at 2:40 pm

Avatar

[...] to say I guess, but here’s a link to what my fellow Jordanian netizens are saying about it: A Sad Day for the Internet in Jordan: A Gag Order. Bam Bam’s World. A Tweet, Facebook, or a Blog Comment or Even an SMS Can Get You To Prison in [...]

28 | Mozzy

January 20th, 2010 at 7:34 pm

Avatar

I won’t change anything. Will still speak my mind freely. Just hope that the government is happy to slowly but steadily destroy their own image towards the rest of the world.
First by not addressing the police issue (hell it was talked about in German news but not in Jordanian) and now by stopping down to a level of freedom like in China.
I say, go ahead, fine me if you like to. I won’t pay. Put me in prison if you like to, I won’t give in and I know that there are a lot of people out there that feel the same.

Let’s get ready to rumble :D

29 | Mozzy

January 20th, 2010 at 10:47 pm

Avatar

Just thought…. does this mean if someone would post some “illegal” content on a governmental website that the government would have to be fined? :) :) :) :) :)

30 | bambam

January 21st, 2010 at 9:47 am

Avatar

not sure about that, maybe it would have to pull a disappearing act on someone?

31 | Jordan court bans ‘net freedom-Global Voices « FACT – Freedom Against Censorship Thailand

January 23rd, 2010 at 8:35 pm

Avatar

[...] to these efforts, BamBam goes over the list of things that may no longer be discussed in the Jordanian [...]

32 | Awful begining.. « Oh Seriously?

January 25th, 2010 at 6:11 pm

Avatar

[...] – A Jordanian court decision on having all Internet sites adhere to the print & publications laws that governs the work of print media was surprising. Now we all know we never had total 100% freedom to say whatever we pleased either as a spoken or written word, but them saying that the law that applies to newspapers for instance will apply to blog posts, Facebook and all other internet websites is a bit too much. Till this day we don’t really know what this means, it might mean that there will be a group of people assigned to following each and every word written on the world wide web by Jordanian citizens but it might also mean (like many before me have suggested) that it’s only a mean of pushing people into self-censoring their own actions online, and i personally think it’s the later. I guess we will just have to wait for a detailed issue on what the ruling actually means. A few good reads on the subject are: >Ahmad Humeid’s Keeping Jordan’s web open and free >Naseem Tawarneh’s On Jordan Censoring The Internet >BamBam’s A Sad Day for The Internet in Jordan: a gag order [...]

33 | KJ

January 26th, 2010 at 8:52 am

Avatar

It’s a minute to midnight on the Web 2.0

Comment Form

Polls

  • How do you think the jordanian court ruling that Media Laws apply to the internet will effect the jordanian electronic scene?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

About The Blog

A space where I dump my pseudo-intellectual farts on unsuspecting readers. You will find rants about Jordan, being a slaving drone, some artistic tangents, and everything from quantum philosophy to disturbing exhibits of how this world is twisted and anything in between.